Introduction
Roof replacement is a significant undertaking for any homeowner, especially in Orlando, Florida, where extreme weather conditions such as hurricanes, high humidity, and intense heat make roofing durability a top priority. This case study examines a real-life successful roof replacement project in Orlando, detailing the challenges, solutions, and final results.
The case study focuses on the Smith family, who needed a full roof replacement due to storm damage. We will explore the issues they faced, the decision-making process, the materials selected, and the final outcome of their roofing project.
1. Project Overview
1.1 Homeowner Background
- Homeowners: John and Lisa Smith
- Location: Orlando, FL
- Home Type: 2,500 sq. ft. single-family home
- Original Roof Material: 15-year-old asphalt shingles
- Reason for Roof Repairs Orlando: Storm damage, leaks, and insurance requirements
1.2 Project Goals
✅ Replace the damaged roof with a durable, energy-efficient, and hurricane-resistant material.
✅ Ensure compliance with Florida Building Codes and insurance requirements.
✅ Improve the home’s curb appeal and resale value.
✅ Stay within a budget of $15,000 – $20,000.
2. Challenges Faced
2.1 Severe Storm Damage
- A Category 2 hurricane hit Orlando in September, causing significant roof damage.
- High winds (up to 100 mph) ripped off shingles and exposed the underlayment.
- Leaks developed in multiple areas, damaging ceilings and insulation.
2.2 Insurance and Permit Issues
- The homeowners’ insurance company required a full roof replacement due to the extent of the damage.
- Navigating Orlando’s permit process and understanding Florida’s roofing regulations added complexity.
2.3 Choosing the Right Roofing Material
- The Smiths needed a durable, weather-resistant roof that could withstand future hurricanes.
- They had to balance budget constraints with long-term cost savings.
2.4 Finding a Reliable Roofing Contractor
- The couple received multiple quotes and had to compare contractors based on reputation, experience, and pricing.
- Many storm-chasing contractors appeared in the area, making it essential to vet roofing companies carefully.
3. Finding the Right Roofing Contractor
3.1 Research and Contractor Selection
- The Smiths requested quotes from five local roofing companies.
- They evaluated each company based on:
🔹 Florida roofing license and insurance
🔹 Better Business Bureau (BBB) rating and online reviews
🔹 Experience with hurricane-resistant roofing systems
🔹 Warranty coverage
3.2 Choosing the Best Fit
After careful consideration, the Smiths selected Orlando Elite Roofing, a company with:
✅ 20+ years of experience in Florida roofing.
✅ A reputation for high-quality craftsmanship and excellent customer service.
✅ A comprehensive warranty covering materials and labor for 10 years.
✅ A detailed, transparent estimate outlining all costs.
4. Roofing Material Selection
4.1 Considering Different Roofing Options
| Roofing Material | Pros | Cons | Cost per sq. ft. |
|---|---|---|---|
| Asphalt Shingles | Affordable, easy to install | Shorter lifespan (20-30 years) | $4 – $7 |
| Metal Roofing | Durable (50+ years), energy-efficient, hurricane-resistant | Higher upfront cost | $7 – $12 |
| Clay Tiles | Excellent durability, aesthetic appeal | Heavy, requires additional structural support | $10 – $20 |
| Synthetic Slate | Lightweight, long-lasting, impact-resistant | Higher initial investment | $8 – $15 |
4.2 The Chosen Roofing Solution
After discussions with their contractor, the Smiths chose architectural asphalt shingles with a Class F wind rating (up to 130 mph) due to:
✅ Affordability – Fit within their $20,000 budget.
✅ Wind & Impact Resistance – Suitable for Orlando’s hurricane season.
✅ Energy Efficiency – Reflective coating to reduce heat absorption.
✅ Manufacturer Warranty – 30-year material warranty.
5. Roof Replacement Process
5.1 Obtaining Permits & Insurance Approval
- The roofing contractor secured permits from the City of Orlando before starting work.
- The insurance claim was processed, covering 60% of the total roof replacement cost.
5.2 Roof Removal & Damage Inspection
- The old shingles were removed, and the underlayment was inspected.
- Hidden damage was found:
🔹 Rotten plywood decking due to prolonged leaks.
🔹 Mold growth in the attic, requiring minor remediation. - Additional repairs added $2,500 to the project cost, but ensured long-term durability.
5.3 Installing the New Roof
- A waterproof synthetic underlayment was installed for additional moisture protection.
- Hurricane-rated architectural shingles were nailed down using ring-shank nails to prevent wind uplift.
- Roof vents were upgraded for better attic ventilation.
- The entire installation took 4 days, ensuring minimal disruption.
5.4 Final Inspection & Cleanup
- The City of Orlando conducted a final building inspection to approve compliance with codes.
- The roofing company provided a 10-year workmanship warranty.
- The yard was cleaned thoroughly, and a magnetic nail sweep was conducted for safety.
Also Read: Roof Maintenance Tips for Orlando Homeowners: A Seasonal Guide
6. Project Outcome & Benefits
6.1 Enhanced Storm Protection
✅ The new shingles withstood a Category 1 storm that hit Orlando the following season.
✅ No missing shingles or leaks were reported, proving the roof’s wind resistance.
6.2 Improved Energy Efficiency
✅ The reflective shingles reduced attic temperatures by 10°F, lowering cooling costs.
✅ The improved ventilation system prevented moisture buildup and mold growth.
6.3 Increased Home Value & Curb Appeal
✅ The Smiths’ property value increased by $15,000 due to the upgraded roof.
✅ The new roof added a modern aesthetic, enhancing curb appeal.
6.4 Long-Term Cost Savings
✅ The 30-year manufacturer warranty ensured peace of mind.
✅ The insurance premium was reduced by 15% due to the hurricane-rated materials.
7. Lessons Learned from the Roof Replacement Project
7.1 Always Get Multiple Estimates
The Smiths saved over $5,000 by comparing quotes from different contractors.
7.2 Choose Quality Over Cheap Materials
Although asphalt shingles were chosen, the higher-end Class F shingles provided better durability and wind resistance.
7.3 Verify Contractor Credentials
By hiring a licensed, insured, and highly rated contractor, the homeowners avoided:
🚫 Unreliable “storm chaser” roofers.
🚫 Hidden costs or subpar workmanship.
7.4 Invest in Preventive Maintenance
Regular roof inspections help catch small issues before they become costly repairs.
8. Conclusion
The Smith family’s Orlando Commercial Roofing Contractors was a major success, thanks to careful planning, the right material selection, and hiring a trusted contractor. By choosing high-quality hurricane-rated asphalt shingles, they ensured storm protection, energy efficiency, and long-term cost savings.
For Orlando homeowners considering a roof replacement, this case study highlights the importance of:
🔹 Assessing storm damage early
🔹 Selecting durable, wind-resistant materials
🔹 Hiring a licensed roofing professional
🔹 Ensuring compliance with Florida’s roofing codes
A well-planned roof replacement is a long-term investment in your home’s safety, efficiency, and value. If your roof is aging or storm-damaged, now is the time to explore your options and upgrade to a hurricane-resistant roofing system!
